Honi Soit
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • UTS POC Revue 2023: The Apocalypse  
    • “You cannot pause ethnic cleansing”: Sydney students call for permanent end to genocide and occupation in Palestine
    • CAPA Board Passes Motion Removing SUPRA Voting Rights 
    • The momentary victory of mass politics: reflections on Kissinger and Australia
    • “We are freedom fighters”: pro-Palestinian protestors march amidst end to seven-day ceasefire
    • An invitation in: SCA’s ‘New Contemporaries’
    • NTEU to delay new fixed-term contract limits that fail to cover higher-education workers
    • Mohammed Shami: The Muslim cricketer who carried an Islamophobic nation to the Men’s Cricket World Cup Final
    • About
    • Print Edition
    • Advertise
    • Locations
    • Contact
    Facebook Instagram X (Twitter) TikTok
    Honi SoitHoni Soit
    Friday, December 8
    • News
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Opinion
    • University
    • Features
    • Perspective
    • Investigation
    • Reviews
    Honi Soit
    Home»News

    VC and FASS Dean dodge wage theft questions at casuals meeting

    Casuals raise concerns about wage theft at the University of Sydney
    By Alice Trenoweth-Creswell and Juliette MarchantJune 17, 2021 News 4 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    The NTEU and Casuals Network today organised a public meeting to discuss casualisation at the University of Sydney with Interim Vice-Chancellor Stephen Garton and Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences Annamarie Jagose.

    Casuals raised concerns surrounding wage theft and unfair working conditions in a unique public forum, with students and permanent staff attending in solidarity with casual staff members.

    The meeting was chaired by casual academic Robert Boncardo and featured a number of student and staff questioners from a variety of faculties. 

    The question of wage theft

    The central question was whether or not the University of Sydney has committed any substantive wage theft. The definition of wage theft was highly contested as Jagose and Garton deflected questions and evidence of widespread underpayment.

    Vice-Chancellor Garton claimed the arguments that have been made previously are “philosophical” rather than “legal”. He argued that “wage theft”, as per the definition in the Enterprise Agreement, had not been committed.

    Professor Jagose claimed what has occurred cannot, definitionally, be considered wage theft. She also cautioned against the nonspecific use of ‘wage theft’. In her view, it has been used as a catch-all term to describe a variety of payment issues within the institution. 

    "Wage theft has appeared as a synonymous category in which all these types of [unpaid hours] have been bundled," says Jagose.

    — Honi Soit (@honi_soit) June 17, 2021

    This position was readily countered by almost all questioners at the event. A casual research assistant within the Faculty of Medicine and Health drew particular attention to the dichotomy between casual staff paid for hours worked and those paid on a piece rate, pointing out the lack of consistency between those in teaching positions and research positions.

    Questions arose about the similarities between the legal case confronting the University of Melbourne, which has pledged $16 million as recompense for wage theft. Garton maintained that this case was distinct from that concerning the University of Sydney, as Melbourne demonstrably did not meet the standards outlined in their Enterprise Agreement. This stance was met with criticism, with a casual noting that the only difference is that the University of Melbourne pays per 3000 words for marking, and the University of Sydney pays per 4500 words.

    Desktop audits and ‘evidence-based’ conversations

    In May 2021, The Casuals Network and National Tertiary Education Union (NTEU) released ‘The Tip of the Iceberg’ report, revealing 90% of participants performed unpaid work during Semester 2, 2020.

    Vice-Chancellor Garton refuted the report by critiquing the sample size and referencing the desktop audit conducted by University administration. 

    The desktop audit of 100 timesheets found little casual underpayment, however casuals argued that the audit was flawed as timesheets do not allow staff to log hours worked in excess of contract.

    “We’ve done a desktop audit, we’ve audited 100 time sheets,” says Garton. The room laughs… “I’ve just explained why you can’t [rely on desktop audits],” says Joel.

    — Honi Soit (@honi_soit) June 17, 2021

    Management’s proposed solutions

    Throughout the hour-long meeting, Jagose and Garton claimed they take allegations of wage theft seriously.

    Garton blamed a lack of government economic support, citing a “broken model propped up by international students.” However, in 2020, the University saw a surplus of over $106.6 million and increased international student revenue. 

    The Vice-Chancellor argued that the workforce needed to diversify and focus more on teaching. He referenced different models in the UK and USA which employ significant numbers of teaching-only staff members. 

    Casual conversions to permanent staff positions

    Emeritus Professor Linda Connor highlighted the difficulty of converting casual staff members into ongoing roles, particularly in the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences. Jagose claims she was shocked to hear this.

    “I look at the four categories [for refusal of conversion], and make a determination as to what is appropriate,” said Jagose. 

    After the meeting, students confronted Garton and Jagose outside Taste Cafe, where the pair continued to evade questions, leaving as students chanted “1, 2, 3, fuck the VC!”

    Photo: Georgia Carr
    casuals NTEU VC

    Keep Reading

    “You cannot pause ethnic cleansing”: Sydney students call for permanent end to genocide and occupation in Palestine

    CAPA Board Passes Motion Removing SUPRA Voting Rights 

    “We are freedom fighters”: pro-Palestinian protestors march amidst end to seven-day ceasefire

    NTEU to delay new fixed-term contract limits that fail to cover higher-education workers

    Tensions rise between Arc and Tharunka over editorial processes

    Seventh consecutive pro-Palestine rally held at Hyde Park

    Just In

    UTS POC Revue 2023: The Apocalypse  

    December 8, 2023

    “You cannot pause ethnic cleansing”: Sydney students call for permanent end to genocide and occupation in Palestine

    December 7, 2023

    CAPA Board Passes Motion Removing SUPRA Voting Rights 

    December 7, 2023

    The momentary victory of mass politics: reflections on Kissinger and Australia

    December 6, 2023
    Editor's Picks

    Puff, puff, pass: What does cannabis legalisation mean for student communities?

    November 1, 2023

    Privacy is not dead, yet

    October 26, 2023

    ‘A patchwork quilt of repression’: The disappearing right to protest in NSW

    October 17, 2023

    The lights are on, but no one’s home: inside USyd’s International House

    October 10, 2023
    Facebook Instagram X (Twitter) TikTok

    From the mines

    • News
    • Analysis
    • Higher Education
    • Culture
    • Features
    • Investigation
    • Comedy
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Misc

     

    • Opinion
    • Perspective
    • Profiles
    • Reviews
    • Science
    • Social
    • Sport
    • SRC Reports
    • Tech

    Admin

    • About
    • Editors
    • Send an Anonymous Tip
    • Write/Produce/Create For Us
    • Print Edition
    • Locations
    • Archive
    • Advertise in Honi Soit
    • Contact Us

    We acknowledge the traditional custodians of this land, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. The University of Sydney – where we write, publish and distribute Honi Soit – is on the sovereign land of these people. As students and journalists, we recognise our complicity in the ongoing colonisation of Indigenous land. In recognition of our privilege, we vow to not only include, but to prioritise and centre the experiences of Indigenous people, and to be reflective when we fail to be a counterpoint to the racism that plagues the mainstream media.

    © 2023 Honi Soit
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms
    • Accessibility

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.