On Sunday, June 23, Dylan Griffiths, an Inner West councillor in the Djarrawunang/Ashfield ward, Palestine Justice Movement, BDS Youth, and Unionists for Palestine held a panel at the Marrickville Pavilion advocating for Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) within the Inner West council.
Arguing against the premise that Palestine is not an issue for local government and is about “rates, road and rubbish”, Griffiths said that in this case, rates matter more than ever, as they are going towards companies complicit in, and profiteering off of genocide in Palestine.
He then spoke about the two ceasefire motions before the Council in November and December 2023, and the open letter put forth by Antony D’Adam MLC and Greens Member for Newtown Jenny Leong. In particular, the stance of Labor councillors and their vote against the motion was spotlighted, with Green Left having reported details from the meeting, and the minutes publicly available.
Griffiths then made the point that the final November motion (“Inner West Council supports ceasefire in Gaza”) only came to fruition after public backlash and the resignation of the Inner West Multicultural Committee.
Tasneen Shubarta of BDS Youth explained their role in empowering youth to end the illegal occupation through “achievable wins” as strategically determined by the BDS national committee. This includes the implementation of Israeli Apartheid Week on university campuses and targeted boycotts against companies like Intel, Sodastream, and Elbit Systems. Shubarta described the BDS movement as “nonviolent and opposed to discrimination”, based on the South African model which saw divestment as a “recognised tool for change.”
Hewlett-Packard (HP) was deemed relevant to the Inner West Council investment portfolio, as well as the Council being serviced digitally by HP. It was argued that if this is the case in one council, it is likely a standard across other councils. HP is directly involved in supplying technology to the Israeli military such as the tiered ID card system and is the exclusive provider of computers for the Israel Defence Forces.
Shubarta stated that councils must:
- Audit their investment portfolio, disclose and divest
- Pledge for an apartheid free zone
- Review policies and ethical practices on an annual basis
Ahmad Abadla, a Palestinian activist from Khan Younis, summarised the legal case for BDS, and spoke of his lived experience in Gaza, particularly four weeks before October 7 and the start of the genocide.
“Gaza is beautiful and will remain beautiful despite the wholesale destruction,” Abadla said, elaborating on his amazement at the ability of Palestinians to find hope and a will to live.
Abadla identified BDS as the best method for people in the West to help Palestinians, and spoke to its narrow beginnings, often deemed “fraught”. He spoke to the history of Jewish businesses being targeted by real antisemites in the 1930s and that Zionists have weaponised this trauma to limit the potential of BDS when it is “one of the most potent tools available for Palestine.”
He continued that under the Genocide Convention, private individuals, corporate actors, and city councils must not be complicit, meaning “there may be real legal and financial consequences for being linked to Israel’s crimes and genocide against Palestinians.”
Abadla implored the Inner West Council to adopt and call for BDS to prevent and punish Israel’s war crimes and genocide, concluding that “if Gaza doesn’t win, we will all lose our conscience and humanity”.
Antony Loewenstein, local resident and author of The Palestine Laboratory: How Israel Exports the Technology of Occupation Around the World (2023), who advocated for a BDS motion proposed in 2011 at the then-Marrickville council spoke next. Loewenstein argued that BDS scares those who oppose it, and so they believe that they can demonise it by framing it as anti-Israel and antisemitic. He then stated that change will not come from a sudden mass movement of Israelis from within, but from an outside movement like BDS applying pressure, similar to the outside forces that were one of the reasons for the fall of apartheid in South Africa.
Lowenstein continued that Israel is petrified of BDS, since it spends massive funds to counter it, and is supported by the US, which has made BDS illegal in over 30 states. He elaborated on the reasoning for BDS, with corporations like Starbucks and McDonalds having supported Israel long before October 7, and that Israel is one of the top 10 arms industries in the world, battle testing its weapons on Palestinians before being sold globally to other countries to deal with their minorities.
He spoke to the criticism of 2011 which viewed BDS as repeating the attacks on Jewish businesses like in Nazi Germany. Loewenstein asserted that BDS is “not going after Jewish people for being Jewish, but for associating and partnering with Israel”, and that all councils must have a Palestinian-led BDS movement.
Lowenstein concluded by predicting that many Western states and elites will remain in support of Israel but that civil society and public opinion are being swayed, especially in the 18-35 age bracket.
What are the next steps?
- Inner West Council’s relation with HP will be questioned by Griffiths in a council meeting in August.
- Community group Inner West 4 Palestine has been formed and its first meeting will occur next Friday, June 28 at the Marrickville Library.
- The process of auditing and disclosure of relationships with complicit companies.
- A motion in the City of Sydney Council will be presented on Monday night at Sydney Town Hall, with a rally outside and bike riders cycling in support.
100 seats were filled up, as people stood outside on the lawns of the Marrickville Pavilion to listen to the panel. Many also participated in the open discussion at the end, including USyd student campers and National Tertiary Education Union (NTEU) members.
Various observations were made including that Marrickville is the only Australian city to have a sister city in Bethlehem.
The following suggestions were made to amplify BDS goals:
- Mobilise community members to attend council meetings and pressure councillors or threaten the loss of their seat in the coming elections in September.
- Check where your superannuation funds are being invested in.
- Send submissions for the council’s anti-racism framework, emphasising all First Nations involvement and justice.
- Rejection of the IHRA definition of antisemitism as it harms the Palestinian solidarity movement.
One NTEU member also suggested an on-the-spot vote for the council to adopt a BDS policy, which saw every attendee put up their hand in support.
It was concluded that contrary to as many would claim, local government has a significant part to play in pushing for BDS.
A livestream of the panel can be found on BDS Youth’s Instagram.
