Close Menu
Honi Soit
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Skank Sinatra Review: Electric, hilarious, and open-hearted
    • Spacey Jane’s  ‘If That Makes Sense’ and Keeping Australian Music Alive
    • Trump administration issues executive order closing CIA black sites, convinced they are “woke” /Satire
    • “Lawfare”: Jewish staff and students rally behind USyd academics now facing federal legal action
    • Interview with Plestia Alaqad on ‘The Eyes of Gaza’
    • Whose Review Is It Anyway?: NUTS’ WPIIA 2025
    •  “Like diaspora, pollen needs to be scattered to different places to survive and grow”: Dual Opening of ‘Germinate/Propagate/Bloom’, and ‘Last Call’ at 4A Centre of Contemporary Asian Art
    • Akinola Davies Jr. on ‘My Father’s Shadow’, Namesakes, and Nostalgia
    • About
    • Print Edition
    • Student Journalism Conference 2025
    • Writing Comp
    • Advertise
    • Locations
    • Contact
    Facebook Instagram X (Twitter) TikTok
    Honi SoitHoni Soit
    Monday, June 23
    • News
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Opinion
    • University
    • Features
    • Perspective
    • Investigation
    • Reviews
    • Comedy
    • Student Journalism Conference 2025
    Honi Soit
    Home»Reviews

    Disobedience paints a bleak tale of faith and forbidden romance

    Chilean director Sebastián Lelio explores a secret lesbian relationship in an Orthodox Jewish community.
    By Nicholas HulmeJune 12, 2018 Reviews 3 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    This piece is from our continuing coverage of Sydney Film Festival over the next month. Check out the rest of the content here. 

    Following his success with the Oscar-winning A Fantastic Woman (2017), Chilean director Sebastián Lelio continues his fascination with the struggle of women in modernity in his first English language film, Disobedience. The film explores the difficulties of being queer in a religious community through the romance between two women Ronit (Rachel Weisz) and Esti (Rachel McAdams)—two women who are forced to suppress their feelings by their strict Jewish Orthodox community.

    The film begins with an opening monologue from Ronit’s estranged father, the elderly Rabbi Rav Krushka (Anton Lesser) who speaks on the free will of man, before he collapses suddenly to the floor. Following his death, Ronit returns to the Orthodox Jewish neighbourhood she grew up in, where she reunites with childhood friends Dovid (Alessandro Nivola) and Esti, who have since married each other. From here, the underlying tensions between Esti and Ronit begin to surface, from moments of childhood reminiscence to Esti’s support of Ronit through a tense family dinner. It is only at the beginning of the second act that the first elements of romance appear on screen with a shared kiss set against the dark, yearning tones of The Cure’s ‘Lovesong’. This slow pacing works well in establishing a sense of emotional repression, while also cementing a sense of realism within the film.

    As Ronit and Esti’s relationship deepens, they become more open in their affections: they hold hands in the park where they shared their first kiss, they embrace in an alleyway, they spend an intimate night in a hotel room. However, these moments are tarred with a sense of anxiety and a knowledge that this cannot be their lives. The bleak, almost monochrome colour palette of the film—rarely varying from black, white and grey—reflects this hopelessness, and harkens back to some of the grimmer scenes in A Fantastic Woman.

    Weisz and McAdams have put painstaking research into their performances, and the setting and the costuming anchor us in our reality. But the script sometimes falls short of the film’s visual attributes, occasionally straying into generic, impassioned one liners. The theme of free will’s central role in the human condition is revisited frequently in the film’s final act. All three of the central characters, in one way or another, espouse the necessity for freedom, which ultimately feels a little forced. The lack of a clear resolution at the close of the film will likely perturb some viewers, but it is an ending that stays true to the realistic portrayal of the hardships queer people face in conservative communities.

    disobedience LGBT queer cinema sff sff2018

    Keep Reading

    Skank Sinatra Review: Electric, hilarious, and open-hearted

    Spacey Jane’s  ‘If That Makes Sense’ and Keeping Australian Music Alive

    Whose Review Is It Anyway?: NUTS’ WPIIA 2025

     “Like diaspora, pollen needs to be scattered to different places to survive and grow”: Dual Opening of ‘Germinate/Propagate/Bloom’, and ‘Last Call’ at 4A Centre of Contemporary Asian Art

    Bach, Handel, Scarlatti, and Rameau walk into the Oldest Sydney Church

    The Anarchy 1138-53: to play or to plunder?

    Just In

    Skank Sinatra Review: Electric, hilarious, and open-hearted

    June 20, 2025

    Spacey Jane’s  ‘If That Makes Sense’ and Keeping Australian Music Alive

    June 20, 2025

    Trump administration issues executive order closing CIA black sites, convinced they are “woke” /Satire

    June 19, 2025

    “Lawfare”: Jewish staff and students rally behind USyd academics now facing federal legal action

    June 19, 2025
    Editor's Picks

    Part One: The Tale of the Corporate University

    May 28, 2025

    “Thank you Conspiracy!” says Capitalism, as it survives another day

    May 21, 2025

    A meditation on God and the impossible pursuit of answers

    May 14, 2025

    We Will Be Remembered As More Than Administrative Errors

    May 7, 2025
    Facebook Instagram X (Twitter) TikTok

    From the mines

    • News
    • Analysis
    • Higher Education
    • Culture
    • Features
    • Investigation
    • Comedy
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Misc

     

    • Opinion
    • Perspective
    • Profiles
    • Reviews
    • Science
    • Social
    • Sport
    • SRC Reports
    • Tech

    Admin

    • About
    • Editors
    • Send an Anonymous Tip
    • Write/Produce/Create For Us
    • Print Edition
    • Locations
    • Archive
    • Advertise in Honi Soit
    • Contact Us

    We acknowledge the traditional custodians of this land, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. The University of Sydney – where we write, publish and distribute Honi Soit – is on the sovereign land of these people. As students and journalists, we recognise our complicity in the ongoing colonisation of Indigenous land. In recognition of our privilege, we vow to not only include, but to prioritise and centre the experiences of Indigenous people, and to be reflective when we fail to be a counterpoint to the racism that plagues the mainstream media.

    © 2025 Honi Soit
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms
    • Accessibility

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.