Close Menu
Honi Soit
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Skank Sinatra Review: Electric, hilarious, and open-hearted
    • Spacey Jane’s  ‘If That Makes Sense’ and Keeping Australian Music Alive
    • Trump administration issues executive order closing CIA black sites, convinced they are “woke” /Satire
    • “Lawfare”: Jewish staff and students rally behind USyd academics now facing federal legal action
    • Interview with Plestia Alaqad on ‘The Eyes of Gaza’
    • Whose Review Is It Anyway?: NUTS’ WPIIA 2025
    •  “Like diaspora, pollen needs to be scattered to different places to survive and grow”: Dual Opening of ‘Germinate/Propagate/Bloom’, and ‘Last Call’ at 4A Centre of Contemporary Asian Art
    • Akinola Davies Jr. on ‘My Father’s Shadow’, Namesakes, and Nostalgia
    • About
    • Print Edition
    • Student Journalism Conference 2025
    • Writing Comp
    • Advertise
    • Locations
    • Contact
    Facebook Instagram X (Twitter) TikTok
    Honi SoitHoni Soit
    Sunday, June 22
    • News
    • Analysis
    • Culture
    • Opinion
    • University
    • Features
    • Perspective
    • Investigation
    • Reviews
    • Comedy
    • Student Journalism Conference 2025
    Honi Soit
    Home»Opinion

    The importance of being earnest

    By James HollowayMay 10, 2016 Opinion 3 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    On May 12 and 13, the 2016 Sydney Uni Revue will be performed in conjunction with the Sydney Comedy Festival. It’s a kind of “best of” show, a compilation of last year’s individual faculty performances showcasing the best sketches, songs and dances of the 2015 season.

    But how good were those performances really? Honi Soit doesn’t have the answers.

    For many readers, scrolling through the review section of the Honi website can feel a little like eavesdropping on a kindergarten show and tell. Each play and musical production is met with only the bare minimum of scrutiny; they are received not with discernment but instead with an automatic chorus of patted backs and high fives. It is a realm dominated by tacitly mandated positivity and dire inoffensiveness, where to lodge an even slightly negative review has been known to generate more drama off stage than on.

    While it is important to celebrate those university productions (and there are many) that well and truly hit the mark, plenty miss it, and to say otherwise is dishonest and even potentially damaging. In our rush to create a culture of growth and positivity we run the risk of doing the opposite. When we refuse to challenge our performers or hold them to a high standard, we risk rewarding and reinforcing mediocrity.

    When it comes to reviews, there are a few factors holding back even the smallest hints of negativity. The first, and probably the most influential, is an unwillingness to upset close friends or future associates. This is understandable. To find yourself aiming crosshairs at the enthusiastic faces of your own peer group can be daunting. But this attitude assumes the term “criticism” need be synonymous with “negativity”, when reviews can and should strive to be constructive and honest without delving into cruelty.

    The second is the risk of being seen to be “taking things too seriously”. This is the University of Sydney, not NIDA or Juilliard – the people performing aren’t professionals. For many, the stage may be a refuge from the artillery fire of the tutorial or Turnitin page. Yet while the theatre is, and should be, a place that celebrates inclusivity, one that encourages enthusiasm and promotes teamwork,  to strive for these values at the expense of critical reporting does a disservice to the ambitions of many of the University’s performers, whose aspirations do lie beyond the humble doors of the Cellar Theatre.

    If the purpose of a review is to indiscriminately celebrate its subjects, what function does it serve in the first place? What incentive is there to read a review when the article is written before the curtains even rise?

    So when it comes to reviewing this year’s productions, let’s practise balance and discernment and challenge our performers because, simply put, sometimes the things we make suck.

    And that’s OK.

    criticism reviews revues Student Theatre SUDS

    Keep Reading

    Spacey Jane’s  ‘If That Makes Sense’ and Keeping Australian Music Alive

    The Wrong Gods Review: Sacred Soil and Shifting Futures

    Romeo & Juliet Review: Where Love Lingers and Time Unfolds

    “This is an open room”: Eureka Day at the Seymour Centre 

    Old Mervs: The ‘Bushman’ identity transformed into modern Australian music

    Everything is Alive at Slowdive

    Just In

    Skank Sinatra Review: Electric, hilarious, and open-hearted

    June 20, 2025

    Spacey Jane’s  ‘If That Makes Sense’ and Keeping Australian Music Alive

    June 20, 2025

    Trump administration issues executive order closing CIA black sites, convinced they are “woke” /Satire

    June 19, 2025

    “Lawfare”: Jewish staff and students rally behind USyd academics now facing federal legal action

    June 19, 2025
    Editor's Picks

    Part One: The Tale of the Corporate University

    May 28, 2025

    “Thank you Conspiracy!” says Capitalism, as it survives another day

    May 21, 2025

    A meditation on God and the impossible pursuit of answers

    May 14, 2025

    We Will Be Remembered As More Than Administrative Errors

    May 7, 2025
    Facebook Instagram X (Twitter) TikTok

    From the mines

    • News
    • Analysis
    • Higher Education
    • Culture
    • Features
    • Investigation
    • Comedy
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Misc

     

    • Opinion
    • Perspective
    • Profiles
    • Reviews
    • Science
    • Social
    • Sport
    • SRC Reports
    • Tech

    Admin

    • About
    • Editors
    • Send an Anonymous Tip
    • Write/Produce/Create For Us
    • Print Edition
    • Locations
    • Archive
    • Advertise in Honi Soit
    • Contact Us

    We acknowledge the traditional custodians of this land, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. The University of Sydney – where we write, publish and distribute Honi Soit – is on the sovereign land of these people. As students and journalists, we recognise our complicity in the ongoing colonisation of Indigenous land. In recognition of our privilege, we vow to not only include, but to prioritise and centre the experiences of Indigenous people, and to be reflective when we fail to be a counterpoint to the racism that plagues the mainstream media.

    © 2025 Honi Soit
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms
    • Accessibility

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.